Shiplap vs Drywall: Which One Should You Choose?

We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

Shiplap and drywalls are two names that always appear before everything else. They possess several advantages over each other. But which is more beneficial to you? To know that, you’ve to compare them directly with each other. 

What are the differences between Shiplap vs Drywall? 

Shiplap might be more expensive than Drywall but it’s cheaper in the long run. It’s also super durable and takes less money to maintain. The installation of Shiplap is super easy and can be done by anyone. Drywalls are quite nice as an alternate option but they can easily get scratched. Shiplap also lets you hang objects very easily. 

Anyhow, that was just a summary of the debate. Keep reading if you want to know more about these two methods and their benefits. 

Let’s not beat the bush around any longer and head right in!

Shiplap vs Drywall: Primary Differences

Going through the basics of two different topics can save a lot of time. Because when comparing you’ll come across terms or facts that you might not know about. 

Similarly, knowing about OSB and Drywall will help you understand them better. It’s an easier way to tackle this issue. 

Here’s a small table that we’ve made just for you- 

Aspects ShiplapDrywall
Price2.50$ to 7.00$ per sq. ft.1.50$ to 1.80$ per sq. ft.
Maintenance CheaperExpensive
DurabilityMore durableModerately durable
InstallationSuper Easy; DIY possible Hard
Appearance More optionsFewer options
Hanging objects EasierHarder
Painting costLowerHigher

After going through the table, which one is giving you a better impression? 

Shiplap vs Drywall: Comprehensive Discussion 

That was just a short preview of the entire debate that we’re going to have. If you’re still confused, don’t worry about it. 

Because we’ve talked about each of these aspects and provided insight. 

Price Point

Since doing the walls takes a lot of money, we’ve prioritized it first. For many people, budget is the first and foremost issue. 

When comparing prices, you’ve to keep two factors in mind. The upfront price and the maintenance cost. We are going to talk about maintenance in a little bit. 

For Shiplap, a single square foot will cost you around 2.5$ to 7$. You may feel like this is super expensive. 

In reality, it is. It’s extremely expensive if you want to get the top-tier Shiplap boards. A single room is going to cost you more than 500$ to 1500$

An average American spends around 1000$ per room using Shiplap. 

On the other hand, Drywall is cheaper. They cost around 1.50$ to 1.80$ per square foot. This is significantly cheaper and makes you think they are worth it. 

But they have more problems than Shiplap. For example, Drywalls can easily get wet near the shower. As a result, you then have to fix the wet drywall near your shower

Winner: Considering nothing but upfront cost, Drywall definitely wins this round. 

Maintenance

Maintenance is the first thing to consider when building a house apart from price. This is where the debate takes a turn and might convince you otherwise.  

Shiplap has no competition in the maintenance category. This is why manufacturers can charge a massive price for their products. 

Shiplap is made of thick wood. You can just use a sponge to wash it clean. Being able to wash it whenever you want, makes it a superior choice. 

Other than that, shiplap is super tough and unmatched against Drywall. They can last for years before getting wears and tears. 

Let’s talk about drywall now. Unfortunately, Drywall’s biggest enemy is water itself. It can get damaged if it contacts water. 

Because of that, you’ll face difficulties keeping the drywall clean. But don’t be too disheartened. Because there are ways to wash a Drywall.

They may not be as good as just a regular damp sponge. But they do work. 

Another thing you’ll have to remember is that it’s very prone to damage. A strong bump or hit from any object can create a dent. 

Winner: Shiplap is a far better option. 

Durability

The durability is always a fair concern because you’re spending a lot of money. Because otherwise, spending all that money just becomes a waste. 

Shiplap is hard lumber that ensures durability. Shiplap offers two types of wood. Plywood and MDF. MDF is a great option if you think money’s going to be too tight. 

On the contrary, Drywalls are also quite strong but nowhere near enough. Drywalls can offer flexibility and some other minor benefits. 

But they easily get buried by the fact that these walls are significantly weak. 

Winner: Shiplap wins the round. 

Here are some options that you may consider- 

Plywood/MDF 
Drywall 

You can now pick whichever you prefer and get it started!

Installation 

Installation is also a great factor to consider when building walls. Because most people may not want to pay a high installation fee. 

Shiplap is super easy to build. With the help of some online tutorials, you can build the wall yourself. The installation cost is also cheaper. 

On the other hand, Drywalls are fairly hard to build. Often it does require a professional to build it. That’s why the installation price of Drywall is quite high. 

There are several other benefits of using Shiplap. Shiplap is easily paintable. You can also hang multiple things without worrying. 

But on the other hand, you always have to worry about Drywall’s weight capacity

Ultimately, whichever you buy, be sure to maintain it properly. With proper care, anything will last for a long time. 

FAQs

Question: Why is shiplap so popular?

Answer: It is due to its extremely easy installation. On top of that, it gives a warm ambient texture. There’s also a lot of design options available. 

Question: Does shiplap ruin your walls?

Answer: Shiplap can only ruin your walls if not installed correctly. It can start rotting if water is not removed. Moisture is shiplap’s biggest flaw as it can get through the gaps. 

Question: Should I nail or screw shiplap?

Answer: Nailing is better than screws. They are faster to install too. Using screws requires pre-drilling which can damage the wood or cause an unintentional split. 

Final Words 

That was all we could gather and explain on Shiplap vs Drywall. Hopefully, we were able to provide you with some good answers and explanations. 

Finally, good luck and happy building!

Richard Allen